Finding Middle Ground in the Controversial Multilateral
Agreement on Investments
The Multilateral Agreement on Investments presents a complex
issue. Proponents argue that without MAI
global trade will stagnate while its ratification will herald a new era
of global prosperity. Critics say that
under MAI, multinational corporations will, among other things, exploit
exploit natural resources and exacerbate the environmental problems that
currently plague our world to an extreme. Is the situation really
this stark? If the agreement is ratified as it currently exists,
this is a valid possibility. However, it is doubtful that the MAI
will be passed in it's current form as the global resistance to it increases.
Yet there are ways to save some of the benefits of MAI while protecting
our environment through the careful and extensive modification of the current
agreement. Some of the possible modifications are listed below.
-
Restrictions on the signers requiring that they have strong,
well enforced environmental laws. This would prevent multinational
corporations from exploiting the often lax environmental laws of developing
nations and also provide an incentive for developing nations to update
their environmental laws;
-
Measures requiring investors to operate under the stronger
of home or host country environmental standards. At present, MAI
allows for foreign investors to take advantage of host counties' less restrictive
environmental regulation. This would require whatever regulation
is stricter to take precedence;
-
Exceptions from MAI conditions in order to protect the environment,
conserve natural resources or support international environmental programs.
-
Measures setting guidelines for appropriate industry conduct
regarding sustainable practices and other behavior towards the environment.
Currently MAI requires host countries to treat companies with a history
of responsible conduct the same as those companies that have exploited
their environment in the past, this would place restrictions on irresponsible
companies and encourage these companies to improve their conduct.
-
Measures requiring a more fair and balanced dispute resolution
process. Currently the companies have all the advantages when bringing
up disputes with their host country. This would allow full public
access to hearings and allow for the representation of environmental interests.
While the original deadlines for the completion of negotiations
are long past, MAI never came to fruitation and is still under consideration.
By writing letters to federal officials and by raising public awareness
through letters to media, you can help play a role in ensuring that an
environmentally responsible agreement on multilateral investment is negotiated
and ratified. Sample letters
can be found on the Links page and these also have possible addressees.
For lettere to the editor, the address is often listed in the Editorial
page and Television news often display their address at the end of the
program. It is important to express your views to public officials.
They do read their mail because they want to know what is important to
their constituents and by telling them you can influence public policy!
| Back
to Issue Guides | | Back
to Index | | Back
to Top of Page |